A flat rate is easy to read. The costs behind it aren’t.

One rate on every card. You can read it in a second, and that’s exactly why so many businesses sign up for it.

But being able to read your fee isn’t the same as understanding the costs behind it.

What you’re actually paying for

Every card type has its own interchange rate, the fee that goes to the bank that issued the card. All the card brands publish their interchange tables. The rates are fixed, not negotiable, and they’re updated twice a year, on April 1 and October 1.

There’s no single rate. Debit cards cost less than credit cards. Business cards carry their own rates, and so do rewards cards. In the United States the size of the sale matters too. So does your type of business, and international cards cost more. And it matters whether the payment is card present or card not present. A card typed into a terminal by hand counts as card not present too.

So the real cost of accepting cards changes with almost every customer.

A flat rate gives you zero visibility of the costs underneath.

Paying the average

With flat-rate pricing, which Stripe and Square use as their standard, you pay the same rate whether your customer taps a debit card or a premium travel card.

Think of a restaurant that charges every table the same bill, no matter what they ordered. Easy at the till, and a bad deal for the table that only had soup.

Cards with lower interchange cost you exactly the same as cards with higher interchange, and you never see the difference.

Yes, a few cards carry interchange above the flat rate, and the processor absorbs that loss. But they’re a very small share of the market, and the margin on everything else more than covers them.

Tiered pricing is less common these days, but you’ll still see it. The processor sorts card types into buckets like “qualified” and “non-qualified” and charges a rate for each. Those buckets aren’t set by the card networks. Each processor decides what goes where. So when a card lands in the expensive bucket, there’s very little to check it against.

Interchange-plus shows you the receipt

Interchange-plus works the other way around. You pay the actual interchange on each sale, plus a set markup from your processor.

Illustrative numbers only: a card with 1.5% interchange and a 0.3% markup costs you 1.8% on that sale. A debit card with lower interchange costs you less, and the markup stays the same.

The statement gets longer, but every line on it means something: what each card cost, and what your processor kept.

Who gets the clear version

Here’s the part we don’t like. Stripe and PayPal do offer interchange-plus, but mainly to larger merchants who negotiate custom pricing. With those providers, a smaller business usually gets the simple number.

It’s the same reason we wrote about flat-rate pricing and small businesses.

To be fair, interchange-plus isn’t automatically cheaper. That depends on your volume, the cards your customers use and the markup you agree. But you’d know. And you can’t question a number you can’t see.

If the fees look fine but cash flow doesn’t, that’s a different question: net or gross deposits.

Want to see last month on interchange-plus? We’ll do the math on your real numbers, card by card.

Contact Us